The city connection should have a screen filter over the hole… and behind that screen is a spring-loaded 1-way check valve (in). Chances are it’s simply stuck open. It happens occasionally.
Remove the screen, and just push the spring plunger in a few times with your finger to exercise the spring… put it back together, and you should be good to go.
Of course, if it still leaks after that… the valve may need replacing. Either the o-ring has deteriorated, or the valve itself.
Here’s a link for the replacement, if needed:
https://youtu.be/f1m1Igy8QGc